Dog food comparison · hill’s science diet alternative

Nextrition vs Hill’s Science Diet Sensitive Stomach & Skin

Hill’s Science Diet is known for its vet-recommended Sensitive Stomach & Skin kibble. Dog parents are switching to Nextrition, a cold-pressed dog food made in the USA, because it’s gentle on sensitive stomachs, packed with real meat and gut support, and easy to try with low-cost trial packs.

Updated October 2026

Nextrition vs Hill’s Science Diet: what’s in the bowl?

Nextrition Cold-Pressed Recipes

Hill’s Science Diet Sensitive Stomach & Skin

Complete & Balanced
Complete & Balanced
Complete & Balanced
Life stages
All life stages, incl. large-breed puppies
Adult recipe
Food format
Gently cold-pressed dry food
Crunchy dry kibble
Protein options
Chicken, beef, lamb or salmon
Chicken (dry recipes)
First ingredient
Real chicken, beef, lamb or salmon
Chicken
Peas
None in any recipe
Yellow peas
Protein (dry matter)
About 31–35%
About 25%
Calories per cup
480–505 kcal
391 kcal
Prebiotics
Chicory root
Beet pulp
Probiotics & postbiotics
Fermentation extracts & yeast culture
Not named on label
Fruits & vegetables
Pumpkin, sweet potato, blueberries & more
Beet pulp & flaxseed
Sample packs
4 recipes · $9.99
None listed‡

Where Nextrition wins

Real meat is the first ingredient in all four recipes.
Prebiotics, probiotics and postbiotics in every recipe.
More protein and no peas in any recipe.
Three chicken-free recipes for dogs sensitive to chicken.
Formulated for all life stages, including large-dog growth.
Four 0.25 lb samples for $9.99, with no auto-subscription.

Where Hill’s Science Diet wins

Lower cost per pound for tighter budgets.
Larger bags, up to 36 lb.
Sold at most pet and grocery stores.
Added glucosamine and chondroitin.

Nextrition is the better fit if…

You want real meat first and no peas.
Your dog needs prebiotic, probiotic and postbiotic support.
Your dog is sensitive to chicken and needs a different protein.
You feed a puppy and an adult and want one food.
Your dog leaves kibble in the bowl.
You want to rotate between four proteins.

Hill’s Science Diet is the better fit if…

Lowest cost per pound and the largest bags matter most.
You want to buy food at a local store.

Which Nextrition recipe fits your dog?

Hill’s Sensitive Stomach & Skin dry food comes in chicken recipes. Nextrition gives you four proteins, including three chicken-free options.

Nextrition cold-pressed dog food recipes
  • Nextrition Chicken Recipe

    Real meat first: real chicken with rice and oats, for firmer stools and less gas.

    Shop the Chicken Recipe
  • Nextrition Beef Recipe

    Real meat first: real beef and beef liver, for strength and energy.

    Shop the Beef Recipe
  • Nextrition Lamb Recipe

    Real meat first: real lamb with barley and millet, for dogs with allergies or tummy troubles.

    Shop the Lamb Recipe
  • Nextrition Salmon Recipe

    Real meat first: real salmon, New Zealand green mussels and kelp, for itchy skin.

    Shop the Salmon Recipe
Our cold-pressed difference

We take a gentler approach to making dry food.

Hill’s Science Diet is extruded under high heat. Nextrition presses real meat, wholesome grains, fruits and vegetables together without high heat or steam.

Hill’s Science Diet Sensitive Stomach & Skin uses beet pulp as a prebiotic fiber. Every Nextrition recipe adds prebiotic chicory root, five probiotic fermentation extracts and postbiotic yeast culture.

Nextrition cold-pressed dog food bag

Our recipe. Your dog’s portion.

Nextrition recipes have 480 to 505 calories per cup, compared with 391 in Hill’s Sensitive Stomach & Skin, so your dog eats fewer cups.

We size every feeding plan to your dog’s weight, age and activity.

Our food stays pantry-ready.

Nextrition is shelf-stable, so real meat needs no fridge, freezer or thawing.

Buy one bag or subscribe and save up to 17%.

We fit the food into your pup’s life.

Hill’s Sensitive Stomach & Skin is for adult dogs only. Every Nextrition recipe is formulated for all life stages, so puppies, adults and seniors can share one bag.

We put more thought into every bowl.

Real meat comes first. No peas in any recipe.
We gently cold-press. No high heat or steam.
We build in gut support. Chicory root, fermentation extracts and yeast culture.
We add fruits and vegetables. Pumpkin, sweet potato and blueberries in every recipe.

We make the first step a small one.

Switching from Hill’s? Try all four Nextrition recipes for $9.99.

Sample orders never start a subscription.

4.8 2,500+ verified reviews

Loved by 2,500+ dog parents

Real reviews from real dog people. See what they're saying below.

  • Made in USA
  • Vet-formulated
  • Cold-pressed
  • No fillers, ever

×

Share your thoughts

Rating is required

We'll send you an email to verify that this review came from you.

Upload up to 10 images and 3 videos (max. file size 2GB)

Nextrition vs Hill’s Science Diet: FAQ

Is Nextrition a good alternative to Hill’s Science Diet Sensitive Stomach & Skin?

Yes. Nextrition is a cold-pressed dog food made in the USA. All four recipes (Chicken, Beef, Lamb and Salmon) put real meat first, contain no peas, include prebiotics, probiotics and postbiotics, and are complete and balanced for all life stages.

Does Hill’s Science Diet Sensitive Stomach & Skin have probiotics?

No probiotics are named on the Hill’s Science Diet Adult Sensitive Stomach & Skin label. It uses beet pulp as a prebiotic fiber. Every Nextrition recipe includes prebiotic chicory root, five probiotic fermentation extracts and postbiotic yeast culture.

Can puppies eat Hill’s Science Diet Sensitive Stomach & Skin?

Hill’s labels the adult formula as not recommended for puppies or pregnant or nursing dogs. Every Nextrition recipe meets AAFCO profiles for all life stages, including growth of large dogs.

What if my dog is sensitive to chicken?

Chicken is one of the most commonly reported food allergens in dogs. Hill’s Science Diet Sensitive Stomach & Skin dry food is made with chicken, while Nextrition offers Beef, Lamb and Salmon recipes with no chicken.

Is Nextrition kibble?

No. Nextrition is cold-pressed dog food. Instead of being extruded under high heat like kibble, the ingredients are gently pressed together without high heat or steam. It is shelf-stable and served dry.

Which has more protein, Nextrition or Hill’s Science Diet?

Nextrition recipes have about 31% to 35% protein on a dry matter basis (26% to 30% minimum as fed), compared with about 25% for Hill’s Science Diet Sensitive Stomach & Skin.

Does Nextrition need to be refrigerated?

No. Nextrition is shelf-stable. Store it in the original bag in a cool, dry place, with no fridge, freezer or thawing.

How much does it cost to try Nextrition?

The Nextrition Trial Variety Pack is $9.99 for four 0.25 lb samples (Chicken, Beef, Lamb and Salmon), and sample orders never start a subscription.

Comparison notes & sources

This comparison uses the four Nextrition recipes (Chicken, Beef, Lamb and Salmon) and Hill’s Science Diet Adult Sensitive Stomach & Skin Chicken & Barley Recipe (dry), based on each brand’s published label as of October 2026. Nextrition dry matter protein is estimated from each recipe’s guaranteed analysis.

‡No Hill’s Science Diet trial pack was found in the seller listings we reviewed. This is not a claim that Hill’s never offers samples.

Hill’s and Science Diet are trademarks of Hill’s Pet Nutrition, Inc. Nextrition is not affiliated with Hill’s Pet Nutrition.

Sources: