Dog food comparison · kirkland dog food alternative

Kirkland Signature Dog Food vs Nextrition

Kirkland Signature is known for big bags of kibble at Costco. Dog parents looking for an alternative to Kirkland dog food are switching to Nextrition, a cold-pressed dog food made in the USA, because it’s lower in fat, has no peas, and comes in smaller bags with no membership needed.

Nextrition vs Kirkland: what’s in the bag?

Nextrition Cold-Pressed Recipes

Kirkland Signature Adult Chicken, Rice & Vegetable

Food format
Cold-pressed at low temperatures
Kibble
Fat (min)
10–12%
16%
Peas
None in any recipe
Peas on the label
Calories per cup
480–505 kcal
393 kcal
Pre-, pro- & postbiotics
All three, in every recipe
Prebiotics & probiotics
Puppies & adults
Every recipe, all life stages
Adult formula, adults only
Bag sizes
4.5, 9, 13.5 & 18 lb
20–25 lb
Where to buy
Online & local pet stores, no membership
Costco warehouses & costco.com
Sample packs
4 recipes · $9.99
Full bags only
Made in
USA
USA

Where Nextrition wins

Cold-pressed at low temperatures, not shaped into kibble.
Lower in fat, with no peas in any recipe.
Prebiotics, probiotics and postbiotics in all four bags.
One recipe for puppies and adults alike.
Bags from 4.5 lb, with no membership needed.
Four recipes to sample for $9.99.

Where Kirkland wins

Easy to grab on a regular Costco run.
Grain-inclusive and grain-free Nature’s Domain lines.
Big bags for homes with several dogs.

Nextrition is the better fit if…

You’re ready to move beyond kibble to a cold-pressed food.
A 25 lb bag lasts your small dog for months.
You don’t have a Costco membership or warehouse nearby.
You’re feeding a puppy and an adult dog together.
You’d like to test four recipes before a full bag.

Kirkland is the better fit if…

You already shop at Costco every week.
You feed several large dogs and buy in bulk.

Which Nextrition recipe fits your dog?

Kirkland Signature splits its range into adult, puppy, small-dog and senior formulas. Every Nextrition recipe fits every life stage, so you only choose the protein.

Nextrition cold-pressed dog food recipes
  • Nextrition Chicken Recipe

    U.S.-sourced chicken with rice and oats, more than 4 lb per bag. A familiar swap for dogs raised on chicken and rice.

    Shop the Chicken Recipe
  • Nextrition Beef Recipe

    Real beef and beef liver lead, with sorghum, oats and millet for a hearty bowl without peas.

    Shop the Beef Recipe
  • Nextrition Lamb Recipe

    30% protein, our highest, for dogs that do better on lamb than on poultry.

    Shop the Lamb Recipe
  • Nextrition Salmon Recipe

    Salmon first, plus New Zealand green mussels and salmon oil, with no pea flour.

    Shop the Salmon Recipe
Kibble vs cold-pressed

A step up from big-bag kibble.

Kibble, like Kirkland Signature, is cooked and shaped into crunchy pellets.

Cold-pressed Nextrition is pressed together gently at low temperatures, which keeps more of the natural nutrients in its whole ingredients.

The result is a denser bowl: 480 to 505 calories a cup, from more than 12 lb of whole ingredients in each 4.5 lb bag.

Nextrition cold-pressed dog food bag

Our recipe. Your dog’s portion.

Because each cup is denser than Kirkland’s 393 calories, most dogs eat a smaller scoop of Nextrition.

Tell our free feeding plan your dog’s weight and activity, and it gives you the daily scoop.

A bag that fits your dog.

Kirkland Signature dry food comes in 20 to 25 lb bags. Nextrition comes in 4.5, 9, 13.5 and 18 lb bags, so you can match the bag to your dog.

No membership needed. Buy one bag, or subscribe to save 10% on every order and up to 17% on larger bags.

More in every scoop than warehouse kibble.

Kirkland Signature is sold at Costco. Nextrition ships to your door from nextritionpet.com and sits on the shelves of local pet stores, with deliveries every 14 to 60 days if you want them.

What’s inside every Nextrition bag.

Meat comes first. Real chicken, beef, lamb or salmon is listed first in every recipe.
Prebiotics, probiotics and postbiotics. Chicory root, five fermentation extracts and yeast culture.
Healthy grains, zero peas. Rice, oats, barley, millet or sorghum in every recipe.
Lighter on fat. 10 to 12% minimum, compared with Kirkland’s 15 to 16%.

Try four recipes for $9.99.

Switching from Kirkland usually means committing to a big bag. Nextrition’s Trial Variety Pack lets your dog taste Chicken, Beef, Lamb and Salmon first.

Four 0.25 lb samples, one $9.99 order, no subscription.

4.8 2,500+ verified reviews

Loved by 2,500+ dog parents

Real reviews from real dog people. See what they're saying below.

  • Made in USA
  • Vet-formulated
  • Cold-pressed
  • No fillers, ever

×

Share your thoughts

Rating is required

We'll send you an email to verify that this review came from you.

Upload up to 10 images and 3 videos (max. file size 2GB)

Kirkland dog food alternative: FAQ

What is a good alternative to Kirkland dog food?

Nextrition is a cold-pressed alternative to Kirkland dog food, made in the USA. It has 10 to 12% fat, no peas in any recipe, and prebiotics, probiotics and postbiotics in every bag. Every recipe works for puppies and adults, bags start at 4.5 lb, and you don’t need a membership to buy it.

Who makes Kirkland dog food?

Costco says all Kirkland Signature dry dog foods are made by Diamond Pet Foods in five company-owned facilities in the United States. Nextrition is an independent brand, also made in the USA.

Can I buy Kirkland dog food without a Costco membership?

Kirkland Signature dog food is sold in Costco warehouses and on costco.com. Nextrition needs no membership: order it online at nextritionpet.com, with free shipping over $30 in the lower 48 states, or pick it up at a local pet store.

Does Kirkland dog food have peas?

Yes. Kirkland Signature Adult Chicken, Rice & Vegetable lists peas, and Nature’s Domain Salmon & Sweet Potato lists peas and pea flour. No Nextrition recipe contains peas.

Does Kirkland dog food have probiotics?

Yes. Kirkland Signature formulas list five probiotics and prebiotic chicory root. Every Nextrition recipe has prebiotic chicory root and five probiotic fermentation extracts, plus postbiotic yeast culture.

Is Kirkland dog food good for puppies?

Kirkland Signature Adult Chicken, Rice & Vegetable is formulated for adult maintenance, and Kirkland sells a separate puppy formula. Every Nextrition recipe is complete and balanced for all life stages, including large-breed puppies, so one bag can feed the whole household.

Which is lower in fat, Kirkland or Nextrition?

Every Nextrition recipe has 10% to 12% minimum fat. Kirkland Signature Adult Chicken, Rice & Vegetable has 16% and Nature’s Domain Salmon & Sweet Potato has 15%, as fed. For sensitive stomachs, lower-fat food is often suggested, so check with your vet.

Can I try Nextrition before buying a full bag?

Yes. Instead of a 20 or 25 lb bag, start with the $9.99 Nextrition Trial Variety Pack: four 0.25 lb samples of Chicken, Beef, Lamb and Salmon, sent as a one-time order with no subscription.

Comparison notes & sources

This comparison covers the four Nextrition cold-pressed recipes (Chicken, Beef, Lamb and Salmon) and Kirkland Signature Adult Formula Chicken, Rice & Vegetable, with Nature’s Domain Salmon & Sweet Potato noted where relevant. It is based on each brand’s published labels and costco.com as of November 2026. Fat figures are guaranteed minimums, as fed.

Bag sizes are for Kirkland Signature dry dog food listed on costco.com. Costco says its Kirkland Signature dry foods are made by Diamond Pet Foods.

Kirkland Signature and Costco are trademarks of Costco Wholesale Corporation. Nextrition is not affiliated with Costco or Diamond Pet Foods.

Sources: