Dog food comparison · taste of the wild alternative

Taste of the Wild vs Nextrition

Taste of the Wild is known for grain-free kibble made with bison, venison and other unusual proteins. Dog parents are switching to Nextrition, a cold-pressed dog food made in the USA, because the meat on the bag comes first, it’s lower in fat with no peas, and every recipe has gut support.

Taste of the Wild vs Nextrition: what comes first?

Nextrition Cold-Pressed Recipes

Taste of the Wild High Prairie

Cold-pressed, not kibble
Yes, pressed at low temperatures
Cooked kibble
Named meat listed first
Yes, in every recipe
Water buffalo first; bison & venison after peas
Lower fat (under 15%)
10–12%
18%
No peas
None in any recipe
Peas & pea flour
Postbiotics
Yeast culture, plus pre- & probiotics
None listed
Fits puppies & adults
Every recipe
This recipe: adults only
Buy direct from the brand
Yes, subscribe & save up to 17%
Sold through retailers
Try 4 recipes for $9.99
Yes, no subscription
Smallest bag 5 lb, one recipe
Made in the USA
Yes
Yes

Where Nextrition wins

The meat in each recipe’s name is its first ingredient.
A lighter bowl at 10 to 12% fat, with zero peas.
Gut support from all three biotics in every recipe.
Cold-pressed at low temperatures instead of kibble.
Every recipe feeds puppies and adults.
Order direct, subscribe to save, or try four for $9.99.

Where Taste of the Wild wins

Bison, venison, wild boar and other unusual proteins.
Grain-free, Ancient Grains and limited-ingredient PREY lines.
Higher protein, at 32% in High Prairie.

Nextrition is the better fit if…

Rich, high-protein kibble is too much for your dog.
You want the meat on the bag to be what’s listed first.
You’d rather skip peas and pea flour.
You want one recipe for your puppy and your adult dog.
You’re ready to move beyond kibble to a cold-pressed food.

Taste of the Wild is the better fit if…

Your dog needs bison, venison or wild boar.
You want a limited-ingredient PREY recipe.

Which Nextrition recipe fits your dog?

Taste of the Wild names its recipes after landscapes. Nextrition names each one after the meat that comes first on the label, and every recipe fits every life stage.

Nextrition cold-pressed dog food recipes
  • Nextrition Chicken Recipe

    Chicken is the first ingredient, with rice and oats instead of peas. A gentle start for dogs coming off rich kibble.

    Shop the Chicken Recipe
  • Nextrition Beef Recipe

    Beef first and beef liver after, with sorghum, oats and millet, for dogs who love a red-meat bowl.

    Shop the Beef Recipe
  • Nextrition Lamb Recipe

    A swap for Sierra Mountain fans: lamb listed first, and 30% protein, our highest.

    Shop the Lamb Recipe
  • Nextrition Salmon Recipe

    A swap for Pacific Stream fans: salmon first, plus New Zealand green mussels and no pea flour.

    Shop the Salmon Recipe
Kibble vs cold-pressed

Not kibble. Cold-pressed.

Kibble, like Taste of the Wild, is cooked and shaped into pellets, with its roasted meats cooked first for flavor.

Cold-pressed Nextrition is gently pressed at low temperatures, a process that holds on to more natural nutrients than traditional extrusion.

Over 12 lb of whole ingredients go into each 4.5 lb bag, for 480 to 505 calories in every cup.

Nextrition cold-pressed dog food bag

Our recipe. Your dog’s portion.

With 480 to 505 calories a cup, compared with High Prairie’s 422, most dogs need a smaller scoop of Nextrition.

Our free feeding plan works out your dog’s daily scoop from weight and activity.

Order it straight from us.

Taste of the Wild is sold through pet stores and online retailers. Nextrition ships from nextritionpet.com and is on local pet store shelves too.

Buy a single bag, or subscribe to save 10% on every order and up to 17% on larger bags.

The lighter alternative to Taste of the Wild.

Like Taste of the Wild, Nextrition is built around real meat. It keeps fat at 10 to 12%, uses healthy grains instead of peas, and adds gut support to every recipe.

What’s inside every Nextrition bag.

The named meat, first. Chicken, beef, lamb or salmon leads its own recipe.
All three biotics. Chicory root, five probiotic fermentation extracts and yeast culture.
Grains, not peas. Rice, oats, barley, millet or sorghum instead of peas and pea flour.
A lighter bowl. 10 to 12% fat, compared with 18% in High Prairie.

Try four recipes for $9.99.

Taste of the Wild’s smallest bag is 5 lb of one recipe. Nextrition’s Trial Variety Pack has Chicken, Beef, Lamb and Salmon, so your dog can pick a favorite.

A one-time $9.99 order that never turns into a subscription.

4.8 2,500+ verified reviews

Loved by 2,500+ dog parents

Real reviews from real dog people. See what they're saying below.

  • Made in USA
  • Vet-formulated
  • Cold-pressed
  • No fillers, ever

×

Share your thoughts

Rating is required

We'll send you an email to verify that this review came from you.

Upload up to 10 images and 3 videos (max. file size 2GB)

Taste of the Wild vs Nextrition: FAQ

Which is better, Taste of the Wild or Nextrition?

It depends on what your dog needs. Taste of the Wild is a grain-free kibble known for unusual proteins like bison and venison, with 32% protein and 18% fat in High Prairie. Nextrition, a cold-pressed dog food made in the USA, is the lighter pick: 10 to 12% fat, no peas, the named meat listed first, and prebiotics, probiotics and postbiotics in every recipe.

Is there a good alternative to Taste of the Wild?

Yes. Nextrition is a cold-pressed alternative to Taste of the Wild with real chicken, beef, lamb or salmon as the first ingredient. Every recipe is complete and balanced for all life stages, and you can try all four for $9.99.

Who makes Taste of the Wild dog food?

Taste of the Wild says it is a wholly owned brand of Diamond Pet Foods, made in seven facilities in the United States with ingredients sourced from around the globe. Nextrition is a separate, independent brand that is also made in the USA.

What is the first ingredient in Taste of the Wild High Prairie?

Water buffalo, followed by lamb meal and chicken meal. Roasted bison and roasted venison come later in the list, after peas and pea flour. In every Nextrition recipe, the meat in the name is the first ingredient.

Does Taste of the Wild have peas?

Yes. High Prairie lists peas and pea flour, and the PREY line uses lentils as its only carbohydrate. No Nextrition recipe contains peas or lentils; they use rice, oats, barley, millet or sorghum instead.

Does Taste of the Wild have probiotics?

Yes. Taste of the Wild adds its K9 Strain Probiotics and prebiotic chicory root. Nextrition goes one step further, with prebiotic chicory root, five probiotic fermentation extracts and postbiotic yeast culture in every recipe.

Is Taste of the Wild high in fat?

High Prairie has 18% minimum fat and Nextrition recipes have 10 to 12%, as fed. If rich food upsets your dog’s stomach, a lower-fat recipe is often suggested, so ask your vet which suits your dog.

Can I try Nextrition before buying a full bag?

Yes. The $9.99 Nextrition Trial Variety Pack brings four 0.25 lb samples, one of each recipe, to your door. It’s a one-time order that never starts a subscription.

Comparison notes & sources

This comparison covers the four Nextrition cold-pressed recipes (Chicken, Beef, Lamb and Salmon) and Taste of the Wild High Prairie Canine Recipe with Roasted Bison & Roasted Venison, with other Taste of the Wild lines noted where relevant. It is based on each brand’s website and published labels as of November 2026. Fat figures are guaranteed minimums, as fed.

Ingredient order is as listed on the Taste of the Wild website. Taste of the Wild says it is a brand of Diamond Pet Foods.

Taste of the Wild is a trademark of its owner. Nextrition is not affiliated with Taste of the Wild or Diamond Pet Foods.

Sources: